In the News: Seattle Fired & the Fight for Religious Liberty
Establishment of the Religious Liberty Commission – The White House
The May 1, 2025 executive order establishes the Religious Liberty Commission to safeguard and promote religious freedom in the United States. The commission is tasked with producing a comprehensive report on the foundations of religious liberty, identifying current threats, and recommending executive or legislative actions to strengthen protections. It will also advise the White House Faith Office and the Domestic Policy Council, with a focus on issues like conscience protections, religious education rights, and the free exercise of faith in public life. The commission is set to expire on July 4, 2026, unless extended by the president.
Seattle firefighters sue city, chief over firings due to vaccine mandate | FOX 13 Seattle
This in-depth piece profiles the lawsuit filed by former SFD firefighters who were terminated after being denied religious accommodations.
“Every plaintiff filed for a religious exemption. None of them were given accommodations, and the suit alleges that no attempt was ever made.”
Report: Seattle Officials Planned to Deny COVID Vax Religious Exemptions, Ignored Fake Vax Cards
This article reveals internal emails and sworn testimony suggesting that city leadership had no intention of honoring religious exemptions.
“City leadership directed departments to deny all accommodation requests unless workers could fully isolate—an unrealistic standard for most.”
It also notes that reports of fake vaccine cards were allegedly ignored by SFD leadership.
2023 06 05 WA faces spate of lawsuits from workers fired for refusing COVID vaccines.pdf
While broader in scope, this article includes SFD among the agencies facing lawsuits for failing to accommodate religious objections.
Gee and Ursula rip Seattle Fire's fake COVID-19 vaccine card allegations
KIRO Newsradio hosts Gee Scott and Ursula Reutin sharply criticized the Seattle Fire Department following an investigation that suggested some firefighters may have used fake COVID-19 vaccine cards to bypass the city’s mandate. The hosts expressed disappointment in Fire Chief Harold Scoggins, who allegedly dismissed concerns raised by a lieutenant about the fraudulent activity, saying it “wasn’t his problem”. Despite the seriousness of the allegations, no disciplinary action has been taken, and the department claims there’s insufficient evidence to identify those involved. The hosts called it a “black mark” on the department and questioned the lack of accountability.
Seattle firefighters suing city over termination after COVID-19 vaccine mandate
Seattle firefighters are suing the city and Fire Chief Harold Scoggins over terminations tied to the COVID-19 vaccine mandate. The plaintiffs argue that their religious exemption requests were based on sincerely held beliefs but were systematically denied without meaningful accommodation. They allege the city prioritized medical exemptions over religious ones and that the exemption process was a “sham,” citing internal communications and testimony from department leadership. The firefighters are seeking lost wages, benefits, and damages.
Investigation Suggests Seattle Firefighters Forged Vaccine Cards to Get Out of Citywide Vaccine Mandate - PubliCola
An independent investigation reported by PubliCola suggests that some Seattle Fire Department employees may have used blank CDC-issued COVID-19 vaccine cards to falsely claim compliance with the city’s vaccine mandate. The cards were allegedly taken from unsecured locations after the department shut down vaccination sites. Despite internal warnings—including one from Lieutenant Lance Fisher to Fire Chief Harold Scoggins—no disciplinary action was taken, and the department cited insufficient evidence to identify individuals involved. Signal messages and testimony hinted at a broader network facilitating the use of fake cards, but the investigation could not conclusively name those responsible.
Fired state workers challenge Washington Covid vaccine mandate at Ninth Circuit | Courthouse News Service
A group of 63 former Washington State Department of Transportation employees is appealing to the Ninth Circuit after their lawsuit challenging the state’s COVID-19 vaccine mandate was dismissed. They argue their constitutional rights were violated when they were fired for refusing the vaccine, despite requesting religious or medical exemptions. The plaintiffs claim the exemption process was hostile toward religion and lacked genuine accommodation efforts.